From a correspondent:
“I returned for the last performance of Elektra at the Met for one last chance to luxuriate in Lise Davidsen’s magnificent artistry pitted against Nina Stemme’s fearlessness only to notice a little white slip in the program announcing that both leads were indisposed. (One assumes it is Covid and hopes for speedy and uneventful recoveries.) Much the same experience on Monday night at Macbeth on Broadway with the super hard-working (and to great effect) Daniel Craig matched ounce-for-ounce in the charisma department by Ruth Negga, the performance of which was prefaced by a speech from the director Sam Gold announcing that, true to its curse, this Macbeth had been afflicted to the extent that understudies of understudies were performing, and to ask for our indulgence that the remarkable stand-in Tina Benko would be on-book.
But back to Elektra: at times like these one considers walking out and cutting one’s losses. Inertia set in and thankfully so: the stand-in Wendy Bryn Harmer was IMHO very much the equal to Davidsen. Harmer has a bright, high and enormous voice, easily sailing over the orchestra (which was kept in check, in volume at least, and perhaps due to the occasion, by conductor Donald Runnicles who led an understated account if it is possible to do so). She is a rare and genuine dramatic soprano, and should be honored as such. At the curtain call she sent multiple kisses to the prompter as if to underscore the immensity of her standing-in achievement. Let us hope that, despite the unfortunate circumstances of her birth — she is American — she is able to command the respect she deserves: I am talking Isolde, Turandot, and anything and everything that Lise Davidsen can sing.
I had the same reaction to hearing mezzo Sasha Cooke, also a Lindenman graduate, not a stand-in but a featured player in Rodelinda in the house and Figaro on the radio — this is a major talent, elegant phrasing and buckets of volume ricocheting about the hall. Her stage presence, which might be called clueless, was endearing and served only to highlight her great and unaffected artistry.
For that matter, let us consider Canadian baritone Etienne Dupuis whom I heard as Rodrigo on the radio: another high, clear-attacking and elegant singer.
These three are great stars, the equal of [INSERT NAME OF LEGENDARY RECORDING ARTIST OF THE STEREOPHONIC AGE HERE]. These are great days for singing.”